Painting an Older or Historic Home in McKinney, TX
· Gary Plask
McKinney is one of the few North Texas suburbs with a real historic core. Around the downtown square, you will find houses with wood siding, deep front porches, tall windows, and trim that has been painted many times over the last century. Painting one of those homes is a different job from repainting a 2010s brick two-story in Stonebridge Ranch or Craig Ranch. This guide from inStyle Painting & Remodeling DFW covers what to check with the City, how older wood fails, and how to plan the job.
We are based in Allen, Texas, and have been painting North Dallas homes since 2008 with professional Sherwin-Williams paint. Questions about your McKinney home? Call (469) 777-8281.

Step 1: Find out whether your home is in the Historic Overlay District
The City of McKinney has a Historic Overlay District with a residential area and a commercial area, plus an inventory of designated and contributing historic properties. A house does not have to be in the district to be historic, but the district rules only apply inside it. You can check your property on the City’s historic district map or by calling the Historic Preservation Office at 972-547-2000.
Here is what the City’s historic preservation FAQ says about paint and exterior work:
- Residential paint colors are not regulated. The ordinance does not regulate paint colors in the residential area of the Historic Overlay District.
- Commercial paint colors are. Changing paint colors in the commercial area requires an approved Certificate of Appropriateness before the work is done.
- Do not paint unpainted brick or stone. The City strongly recommends against it.
- Do not sandblast. If paint is being removed from masonry, the City recommends gentle methods instead of sandblasting or other abrasive blasting.
- Changes to features need review. Replacing siding, windows, or doors, removing historic trim, or adding or removing shutters, porches, and railings are examples of changes the City regulates.
- In-kind maintenance usually does not. Painting, repairs, and replacing materials with matching materials typically do not need permission, but the City suggests talking with the Historic Preservation Office first to confirm your plans count as maintenance.
Source: City of McKinney Historic Preservation FAQ. Rules can change, so confirm with the City before you schedule.
Step 2: Understand how old wood paint fails
Older McKinney homes usually fail in a few familiar ways:
- Peeling down to bare wood on the south and west sides, where the sun is strongest.
- Many layers of old paint that crack and lift together, especially on window trim and porch rails.
- Damp porch ceilings and floors, where water sits longer and paint lets go.
- Open joints where clay soil movement and age have pulled trim and siding apart.
- Previous paint over dirt or chalk, which never bonded well in the first place.
A new coat over any of these problems will fail in the same place. The money in a historic exterior goes into prep.
Step 3: Plan for lead-safe work on pre-1978 homes
Many homes near the square were built long before 1978, the year lead-based paint was banned for residential use in the United States. Older layers under the current paint may contain lead. That matters when paint is scraped or sanded, because the dust is the hazard. Ask any painter you hire how they will handle older layers, and if you are unsure whether lead is present, testing is the way to know. The EPA’s lead renovation guidance is a good starting point.
Step 4: Choose colors that fit the house
Because residential colors are not regulated by the historic ordinance, the choice is yours. Many owners still look at the era of the house for ideas. A Victorian with lots of trim detail can take a body color plus one or two trim and accent colors. A craftsman bungalow often looks right with earthy body colors and a contrasting trim. A simple farmhouse style can work with a single body color and white or off-white trim. Sample on the house, on both a sunny and a shaded side, before you commit. If you would like help, ask about our color consultation.
Step 5: Know what the job will involve
A historic exterior usually takes longer than a newer brick home of the same size, because more of it is painted and more of it needs hand work. A typical scope includes:
- Washing to remove dirt, chalk, and mildew, then dry time.
- Scraping and sanding loose paint, and feathering the edges so they do not show.
- Wood repair or replacement in kind where boards are soft, using matching material.
- Priming bare wood and repairs.
- Caulking open joints, but not sealing gaps that are meant to let the siding breathe.
- Two finish coats of an exterior product matched to the surface.
- Brush and roller work on trim, windows, and porch details.
Interior work in a historic house is simpler on the paperwork side. The City’s FAQ says the Historic Preservation Office does not monitor interior changes, though it encourages owners to keep interior historic features. Plaster walls and original stained wood are common inside, and both need a different approach than drywall.
Older homes outside the district
Plenty of McKinney homes outside the overlay district are older too, and some sit in neighborhoods with HOAs. If you live in a master-planned community like Stonebridge Ranch, Craig Ranch, Tucker Hill, or Trinity Falls, your HOA’s architectural rules apply instead, and exterior color changes usually need approval.
Getting an estimate
When you call, tell us the address, roughly when the house was built, and whether it is in the Historic Overlay District. We will walk every side of the house and give you a written quote. Exterior painting starts at $1,299, and older wood homes are quoted on the prep they actually need.
Learn more on our McKinney painting page and our exterior painting in McKinney page.
Painting historic homes in McKinney FAQs
Can I paint my house any color in McKinney’s historic district?
According to the City’s historic preservation FAQ, the ordinance does not regulate paint colors in the residential area of the Historic Overlay District. Color changes in the commercial area require an approved Certificate of Appropriateness.
Can I paint the brick on my historic McKinney home?
The City strongly recommends against painting unpainted brick or stone in the historic district.
Do I need permission to repaint and make small repairs?
The City says in-kind maintenance, like painting and replacing materials with matching materials, typically does not need permission, but it recommends checking with the Historic Preservation Office first.
Does an older home cost more to paint?
Usually, because more of the exterior is painted wood and more of it needs scraping, priming, and hand work. Exterior painting starts at $1,299, and we quote the prep your house needs.
Who do I call with historic district questions?
The City of McKinney Historic Preservation Office, at 972-547-2000.
Call (469) 777-8281 or request a free estimate for your McKinney home.