Sherwin-Williams vs Benjamin Moore for Texas Exteriors

· Gary Plask

Craftsman-style home with brick and fiber-cement siding and fresh exterior paint

Sherwin-Williams and Benjamin Moore are the two paint brands homeowners ask about most when planning an exterior repaint. Both make excellent exterior paint. The bigger question for a house in Allen, McKinney, Frisco, or Plano is which product line fits North Texas conditions, and how much the prep and application matter compared to the label on the can. This guide from inStyle Painting & Remodeling DFW gives a practical comparison.

We are based in Allen, Texas, have been painting North Dallas homes since 2008, and use professional Sherwin-Williams paint. We will explain why below, and we will be fair to Benjamin Moore too. Questions about your exterior? Call (469) 777-8281.

Freshly painted two-story house with siding and a colored front door at dusk
Example exterior project. Photo: Binyamin Mellish, Pexels
Painter masking windows on a house exterior before painting
Example of exterior paint preparation. Photo: Matt Adams, Unsplash

What North Texas does to exterior paint

Our climate is hard on paint in a few specific ways:

  • Intense UV and long summers fade colors and break down the paint film, especially on south- and west-facing walls.
  • Big temperature swings make wood and siding expand and contract, which stresses caulk and paint.
  • Hail and strong storms can damage siding and trim.
  • Expansive clay soils move foundations and open joints.
  • Humidity near lakes, such as around Lewisville Lake, encourages mildew on shaded sides.

Any premium exterior paint is designed for weather. What you want is good UV and fade resistance, flexibility, and mildew resistance.

Sherwin-Williams exterior lines

Sherwin-Williams offers several exterior grades. The ones homeowners hear about most:

  • Emerald Exterior: Sherwin-Williams’ top-tier exterior line, with strong color retention and durability.
  • Duration Exterior: a long-standing premium line with a thick, flexible film.
  • SuperPaint Exterior: a solid mid-premium option, often used where budget matters.
  • Resilience Exterior: designed to resist early moisture, helpful when weather may turn soon after painting.

Benjamin Moore exterior lines

Benjamin Moore’s well-known exterior products include:

  • Aura Exterior: Benjamin Moore’s premium line, known for rich color and fade resistance.
  • Regal Select Exterior: a popular premium option for siding and trim.
  • Element Guard: a durable exterior line with mildew resistance.

How they compare in practice

At the premium level, both brands perform well. In our experience the differences that matter most to homeowners are practical:

  • Availability. Sherwin-Williams has many stores across Collin County, which makes it easy to get product, touch-up paint, and exact color matches quickly.
  • Color names. Many HOAs in Frisco, McKinney, and Prosper publish approved palettes using Sherwin-Williams colors. Either brand can usually match a color, but using the brand on the palette avoids confusion.
  • Consistency. Using one brand on every job means we know exactly how the product applies, dries, and covers in our heat.
  • Cost. Premium lines from both brands are in a similar range. The product grade you choose matters more than the brand.

That is why we use Sherwin-Williams. If you strongly prefer Benjamin Moore, ask at your estimate and we can talk it through.

Prep matters more than brand

The most expensive paint will still fail early on a dirty, chalky, or peeling surface. What really decides how long an exterior paint job lasts in North Texas:

  • Washing off dirt, chalk, and mildew. See power washing.
  • Scraping and sanding loose paint.
  • Repairing or replacing rotted wood.
  • Priming bare wood and repairs.
  • Caulking open joints at trim, windows, and siding.
  • Applying in the right conditions. Painting in direct summer sun can cause problems. Our North Texas heat guide explains how we schedule around it.

For how long a good job lasts, see how long exterior paint lasts in North Texas.

Color retention on sun-facing walls

Deep colors such as navy, black, and dark bronze are popular on Collin County trim, shutters, and front doors. Darker colors absorb more heat and can show fading sooner on south- and west-facing surfaces. Premium lines from either brand are formulated to hold color better, which is one reason we suggest a top-tier product when you choose a dark exterior color. Lighter colors are generally more forgiving in our sun.

Questions to ask any painter

Whichever brand you choose, ask your painter which exact product line and sheen they plan to use, how many coats are included, what prep is included, and how they handle rotted wood they find during the job. Those answers tell you more about how long the paint will last than the brand name does.

Sheen for exteriors

Most siding looks best in flat or satin, which hides surface flaws. Trim, doors, and shutters usually get satin or semi-gloss, which sheds water and wipes clean.

What it costs

Exterior painting starts at $1,299. The final price depends on house size, the amount of trim and wood, repairs, the product line, and colors, and you get a written quote. See exterior painting in Allen, exterior painting in McKinney, and exterior painting in Frisco.

Sherwin-Williams vs Benjamin Moore FAQs

Is Sherwin-Williams or Benjamin Moore better for exteriors in Texas?

Both make excellent premium exterior paint. The product grade and the quality of prep matter more than the brand. We use Sherwin-Williams for its local availability and consistency.

Which Sherwin-Williams exterior paint is best?

Emerald and Duration are Sherwin-Williams’ premium exterior lines. We recommend a product for your house based on surface, exposure, and budget at the estimate.

Can you match a Benjamin Moore color with Sherwin-Williams paint?

Usually, yes. If your HOA palette names a specific brand, we check it so the approved color stays exact.

What sheen should I use on exterior siding?

Flat or satin is common on siding, with satin or semi-gloss on trim and doors.

How much does exterior painting cost?

Exterior painting starts at $1,299, with a written quote based on your house, repairs, and colors.

Call (469) 777-8281 or request a free estimate for your exterior.

Call Free Estimate